The impact of legal formalism on proving rights
Keywords:
Formalism, Arbitrariness, Evidence, RightsAbstract
Legal formalism is one of the most important principles that are concerned with taking into account the organizational aspect of laws when contracting or judicial procedures when filing lawsuits before the judiciary, whether in terms of determining the judicial jurisdiction of the competent court to consider the dispute or the procedures and deadlines that should be taken into account when filing the lawsuit.
In fact, there is another type of formalism, which is the contractual formalism that the contracting parties agree upon. It is known that formalism plays a major role in maintaining order in general and preserving and taking into account the organizational aspect of applying the law and taking into account its procedures.
But the law has been enacted to preserve rights from loss and protect the weak party in transactions and regulate the relationship between people to regulate procedures, whether they are legal formalities that regulate contracting or procedural formalities that regulate litigation procedures.
Violating this formality results in the invalidity of the procedure and thus the loss of the right for which the formality was enacted to preserve and regulate its procedures, and thus the means prevail over the goal.
Here lies the importance of the research in setting controls for the formality to benefit from it without resulting in obstructing the judicial claim or slowing down the procedures or invalidating the action through what we will explain in our research.
References
First/ Books:
• Dr. Ahmed Hashmat Abu Steit, Research in the Principles of Law, Law and Economics Magazine, Fifth Year, Sixth Issue, 1935 AD.
• Prof. Dr. Mahmoud Abdel Rahman - General Theory of Obligations, Part One, Sources of Obligations, Dar Al Nahda Al Arabiya.
• Dr. Muhammad Nour Farahat, Society, Sharia and Law, Kitab Al Hilal, Issue 426, Ramadan 1406, June 1986 AD.
• Dr. Tharwat Anis Al-Asyuti: "The Legal Approach between Capitalism and Socialism.
• Dr. Nadhir Bin Amou: Special Contracts, Sale and Exchange, University Publishing Center, Tunis 2007
• Dr. Abdul Aziz Abdul Hafeez: Formal Legal Action in Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Golden Eagle for Printing and Publishing, Cairo2000.
Second/ Research:
• Dr. Mustafa Fadhel Karim Al-Khafaji: History of Law in Ancient Societies, Babel Center Journal, Volume Three, Issue Two.
• Prof. Dr. Sufi Abu Talib: History of Legal and Social Systems - Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya1986
• Ibrahim Abdullah Issa: The Contemporary Methodology of Ibn Khaldun, Edition 2006.
• Dr. Muhammad Abdul Hamid Abdul Majeed Al-Alawi: The Importance of Roman Law and the Stages of Its Development - Tihama Magazine Issue (10) Iraq.
• Dr. Muhammad Nour Farhat, Legitimacy and Social Interest, A Comparison between the History of Legal Thought and Islamic Jurisprudence, National Criminal Journal, issued by the National Center for Social Research Criminal, Egypt, Issue 1 and 2, March-June 1976
Third/ Theses and Dissertations:
• Dr. Fathi Wali, The Theory of Nullity in the Code of Civil Procedure, Cairo University Dissertation, 1959, First Edition, Maaref Establishment, Alexandria.
• Dr. Abdul Rashid Abdul Hafez: Formal Disposition in Islamic Jurisprudence (Islamic Law), PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Cairo University 2000
• Dr. Hassan Marouf: The Idea of Formalism and Its Applications in Contracts, PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, University of Baghdad 2004)
• Researcher/ Nasima Hashoud: Formalism in Real Estate Sales (Analytical Study) - Master's Thesis - Contracts and Liability Branch - Faculty of Law - University of Algiers - 2002/2003.
• Researcher/ Latifa Dahmani: Formalism in Civil Contracts, Master's Thesis, Abu Bakr Belkaid University, Tlemcen (2003)
• Dr. Mohamed El-Sawy Mustafa Ibrahim, The Form of Civil Litigation in Egyptian and French Legislation, PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Zagazig University.
• Prof. Dr. Sayed Abdel Hamid Ali Fouda: The Principle of the Authority of Administration between Roman Law and Islamic Jurisprudence, PhD Thesis, Faculty of Law, Cairo University.
Fourth/ Legislation:
(International Agreements, Laws, Regulations and Instructions)
• Egyptian Civil Law.
• Algerian Civil Law
• Civil Transactions System.
• Saudi Evidence System.
• French Civil Law
Fifth/ Judicial Decisions:
Egyptian Court of Cassation: Cassation (29/3/1951) Appeal No. (26 of 19 Q)
Sixth/ Websites:
• https://www.boe.gov.sa/ar/Pages/default.aspx
Seventh/ Foreign Sources:
• La formeestce qui concrétisel’extériorisation de la volonté des parties op cit.
• Repertoite Dalloz, Precite, v. action sect.